Support |
Zune.net
Zune Forums > music talk > music discussio... >

re: Nirvana or Pearl Jam?

Started by Michaelmissy at 10/2/2009 04:35:45. Topic has 13 replies.
sort posts by:oldest / newest
Page 1 of 2 (14 items)
1 2 >

Join Date: 5/30/2008 03:42:26

Posts: 20
10/2/2009 04:35:45
Nirvana or Pearl Jam?
NIRVANA.

1: You probably wouldnt even have heard of Pearl Jam with out them

2: In Utero is possibly the most artistic and emotionally enthralling album I have ever heard. Uncomparable.
0 helpful ratings, 0 not helpful ratings
Was this post helpful? Yes No

Join Date: 7/30/2009 06:11:29

Posts: 3
10/2/2009 04:49:15
re: Nirvana or Pearl Jam?
Nirvana!
0 helpful ratings, 0 not helpful ratings
Was this post helpful? Yes No

Join Date: 5/8/2009 00:56:06

Posts: 63
10/2/2009 16:04:06
re: Nirvana or Pearl Jam?
Nirvana, I find myself skipping less songs when I listen to them. Pearl Jam is good don't get me wrong.

defining my reality
0 helpful ratings, 0 not helpful ratings
Was this post helpful? Yes No

Join Date: 12/9/2007 02:17:17

Posts: 94
10/21/2009 14:18:13
re: Nirvana or Pearl Jam?
Nirvana.
0 helpful ratings, 0 not helpful ratings
Was this post helpful? Yes No

Join Date: 11/14/2007 19:52:42

Posts: 1,191
10/21/2009 15:28:28
re: Nirvana or Pearl Jam?

Many other artists/genres before Nirvana put Seattle on the map musically. Nirvana brought MTV and the rest of the world to Seattle and made grunge a household name. If it were not for Mudhoney or Mother Love Bone, neither Nirvana or Pearl Jam might exist...those bands are the definition of grunge.

To the question, I'll have to pick Pearl Jam. For the simple fact that they are still around making music, I'm not a huge fan of suicide, it proves nothing and Kobain took away other band members chances of making good music for many years.

Nirvana was good...just have to wonder how good they could have been.

Zune is AWESOME!!...since Nov 2006 Black30GB and Pink30GB (my wifes'!!!)
0 helpful ratings, 0 not helpful ratings
Was this post helpful? Yes No

Join Date: 6/8/2008 04:48:29

Posts: 455
10/21/2009 20:27:46
re: Nirvana or Pearl Jam?

IMO:

Don't get me wrong Nirvana was good, but not my thing. Not to take away from dead people's accomplishments, but when a band or artist goes for a few really good years then dies or disbands, then people think that they would have kept on going and that they could do no wrong. Same thing happened with Jimi Hendrix and Janis Joplin. If you want to pull the card that we wouldn't have heard of Pearl Jam without Nirvana, it might be true but it gives better a whole new meaning. I might be over-analyzing this.

New Amon Amarth song available, check out their myspace!
0 helpful ratings, 0 not helpful ratings
Was this post helpful? Yes No

Join Date: 11/14/2007 19:52:42

Posts: 1,191
10/21/2009 21:28:28
re: Nirvana or Pearl Jam?
Its true if we only look at longevity of a band, then Nirvana was not better than Pearl Jam since PJ is still around making music, as well as Alice In Chains and Melvins (another grunge originator). Jimi and Janis would have been amazing had they stayed alive IMO.....I mean when you look at that time frame, look at the success of Santana, Grateful Dead and Journey......Right now Jimi would be playing with Eric Clapton on his Crossroads tours along with all the other guitar greats, we can all dream, because that would be friggin AMAZING!!!!!!

Zune is AWESOME!!...since Nov 2006 Black30GB and Pink30GB (my wifes'!!!)
0 helpful ratings, 0 not helpful ratings
Was this post helpful? Yes No

Join Date: 5/30/2008 03:42:26

Posts: 20
10/23/2009 02:22:34
re: Nirvana or Pearl Jam?
True. Both sets of bands acomplished huge feats.
0 helpful ratings, 0 not helpful ratings
Was this post helpful? Yes No

Join Date: 11/16/2007 14:55:58

Posts: 26
11/18/2009 20:01:07
re: Nirvana or Pearl Jam?
i gotta go with pearl jam, to answer the question but alice in chains is great as well. also soundgarden had chris cornell not left the group. that's just me but i am a little biased because i grew up in seattle and witnessed them all blow up seemingly overnight, mainly because of the nevermind album, but there first album bleach was just as good.

I live life by the tune of my own drum
0 helpful ratings, 0 not helpful ratings
Was this post helpful? Yes No

Join Date: 10/22/2009 17:13:55

Posts: 106
11/19/2009 18:37:14
re: Nirvana or Pearl Jam?
 SHAGGGADELLIC wrote:

IMO:

Don't get me wrong Nirvana was good, but not my thing. Not to take away from dead people's accomplishments, but when a band or artist goes for a few really good years then dies or disbands, then people think that they would have kept on going and that they could do no wrong. Same thing happened with Jimi Hendrix and Janis Joplin. If you want to pull the card that we wouldn't have heard of Pearl Jam without Nirvana, it might be true but it gives better a whole new meaning. I might be over-analyzing this.


I totally agree with this, except I don't think Nirvana was a good band. But that's just my opinion.

Wicked is as wicked does and if I lose control
Is this the way that hell is gonna be?
0 helpful ratings, 0 not helpful ratings
Was this post helpful? Yes No

Join Date: 12/9/2007 02:17:17

Posts: 94
11/19/2009 20:44:16
re: Nirvana or Pearl Jam?
Nirvana.
0 helpful ratings, 0 not helpful ratings
Was this post helpful? Yes No

Join Date: 9/16/2009 03:36:50

Posts: 13
11/21/2009 04:55:48
re: Nirvana or Pearl Jam?

Most definitely Nirvana.  Pearl Jam is a great band with lots more technical talent and a long discography.  But Kurt Cobain's raw talent is just genius.  In Utero was an artistic achievement.  Kurt felt remorse for "selling out" with Nevermind and came back with an album that challenged the band's fan base in a way that most bands would not be able to, even if they dared to. 

There would be no Pearl Jam today without Nirvana.  And lets not forget that Nirvana's career in the spotlight was so short, yet its influence continues for almost 20 years.  That says alot. 

I totally respect Pearl Jam and anyone who believes they were the better band.  But to me, its no contest.
1 helpful ratings, 0 not helpful ratings
Was this post helpful? Yes No
Page 1 of 2 (14 items)
1 2 >
Zune Forums > music talk > music discussio... > re: Nirvana or Pearl Jam?
©2009 Microsoft Corporation. All Rights Reserved