I've had a few iPods now, but disliked being chained to iTunes through their DRM practices. A few months ago, I got a great deal on a refurbished Zune, and switched over. It was an expensive, annoying process, but I did it. The functionality of the player was fantastic. It took some getting used to a new interface, but the smart playlists worked great, and most of my ratings came over when I switched. I really enjoyed the Zune.
My listening habits are simple. I just delete any songs I don't like. Those I keep, I rate from 1 to 5, based on how frequently I want to hear them. Then I set up a smart playlist that randomly selects songs to play with their frequency based on the rating. It took six inter-related playlists to make that happen on the iPod, but Zune was able to do it in one fell swoop!
Imagine, then, my complete shock and disappointment at the new software. First, all my painstaking rating of thousands of songs is now completely inaccessible on the Zune. Second, even if I could access it, the smart playlist that made all that work worthwhile is no longer an option. Instead, I'm left with manual playlists, and the incomprehensibly useless 'like' and 'dislike' rating system. I'm not sure how to explain to you the complete worthlessness of a rating system for songs I dislike. The whole point of digital media is that I'm not stuck with songs I dislike; I just leave those on the album. What am I even going to do with a 'disliked' song list? The flag system worked perfectly well for identifying songs I might want to edit or delete. You've taken a set of very useful tools, and eliminated them for... well, I can't really tell what the exchange was on that, which is why I guess you're losing me as a customer.
Even the changes to the player firmware make no sense. Why make the main menu too big to fit on the screen? How does that help? The rest of the hardware UI type is tiny, so you aren't even making it more accessible for users with poor vision, since they presumably wouldn't be able to read the menus further in. It seems like a purely aesthetic choice that made no consideration of functionality... which is a baffling move from a company that does so well with ergonomics in mice, keyboards, and business software.
So I'm glad I got the Zune player at a great price, because it is now just a portable drive. As much as I hate to do it, it's back to the iPod for me. I certainly now regret buying a car adapter and case for the Zune, since they were only useful for a couple of months. Since I can't roll back to the old software, it's now all just money down the drain... which of course ultimately leads to more money for your competitors since I'll have to go back to buying thing from them. No one wins in this arrangement, and I am completely baffled by the decisions made in crafting this new software.