How much music do you have in your collection? It seems to me, as many others have said, this software is OK if you have a smallish collection. I would litterally cry if I had to manage my 23k songs with Zune. It's simply impracticle and unweildy! Also, again as noted by many others, NOONE should be having problems with files from major-lables, top 40, top 100 stuff, but when you have obscure out of print albums, live recordings, tiny indy lables etc. it's not so easy.
Maybe the Zune works great for casual Billboard Top 100, bubble gum or ubiquitous classic rock (ie yesterday's top 100) [though I still would atribut that to low expectations/needs] but ANYONE with a sizable collection who says the love the Zune software or it works well is full of sh!t. There are no two ways about it.
Even fanboi #1 (he who's name must not be said), candidly admits that he HAS TO use 3rd party software to manage his music. He thinks that those of us who expect more are "lazy" 'cause we want the software "to do everything." I say that sh!t is HILARIOUS 'cause all I want the software to do is to match the features of almost every other media management software available, including WM-11. Believe you me, everything I want Zune to be able to do, I can do right now, that is - right this very moment, WITHOUT ISSUE in iTunes or in WinAmp, or in WM-11. That's all, this is very simple.
It seems to me it really doesn't matter whether your tone is troll-like or somewhat more conciliatory, there's really nothing to argue here. This software is subpar. Demonstrably so. If it works for you, great, wonderful. But if it does work for you, then why are you posting on this thread??? You read the title right????
Microsoft does not need your 'backup'. What they need is to get their sh!t together. It's an awful product, and the people that feel the need to defend it out of some twisted sense of righteousness, kooky corporate pride is probably the saddest commentary ever on how truly pathetic our nation has become. It really is, as someone suggested, like you've got Stockholm syndrome. Free your mind.
In the end, these are gadgets folks, if yours works the way you want it to then GREAT- go out and play. Leave those of us who want/expect more to do our bitching in peace. When Microsoft improves the product, no thanks to you, you'll be the beneficiary of our labor. It's a win-win for you.
Don't hate in '08! I deserve better than this, whether you think you do or not.
Zune 30gb? - Waste! iPod Classic, 160gb - Dusty. iPhone wife has it. iPhone 3g, posting from it. :) Suck it Zune!